Pros & Cons: Plant-Derived Terpenes vs. Cannabis Extracted

Ever wonder why cannabis strains all taste, smell, and affect the mind and body differently? For many years, THC and CBD dominated the conversation surrounding marijuana’s effects, but today researchers and consumers understand more about this miraculously complex plant. Cannabis innovation today involves the distinct aromas and flavors of terpenes, which are compounds found in marijuana’s sticky resin glands as well as most plants, fruits and vegetables on the planet.

Companies all over the US are infusing cannabis tinctures, vaping oils, topicals and edibles with terpenes to create custom flavor and therapeutic profiles. Instead of extracting terpenes from marijuana plants however, many manufacturers are getting creative by using plant-based terpenes that mimic the original cannabis profiles. These products might be marketed as broad or full-spectrum because they contain terpenes as well as whole-plant cannabinoids like THC and CBD.

The idea is that regardless of the source, all terpenes synergize with cannabinoids in these whole-plant blends to enhance medicinal benefits while counteracting potential side effects. This concept is backed by research and is known as the Entourage Effect.

In this post:

  • The debate
  • How terpenes work
  • Predominant terpenes
  • The trouble with terpenes
  • Modernists argument
  • Purists argument
  • Concluding the debate

Plant vs. Cannabis Terpene Debate

While the flavor, fragrance, and overall chemical profile between plant and cannabis terpenes are the same, there’s a growing debate about how safe and effective the non-cannabis infusions are. Cannabis purists question these scientific blends, while modern cannabis companies argue the vast benefits of leveraging readily-available plant terpenes.

So how exactly do terpenes work, and what are the pros and cons of plant-based vs cannabis terpenes? Terpenes are no doubt gaining in popularity and we see it as more and more clients request terpene profile testing for hemp and cannabis. Let’s explore further.

How Terpenes Work

Research shows that terpenes, along with THC and CBD, bind to chemical receptors in the brain and body sending signals to help regulate the systems for optimal health. Some benefits include anti-inflammatory support, relaxation, pain relief, and sedation.

Cannabis contains hundreds of terpenes, and only terpene profile tests can provide the precise concentration of every single one. Notably, the most popular and concentrated terpenes are Limonene, Myrcene, and Pinene.

Predominant Terpenes

Limonene

Limonene is the second most prominent terpene found in all of the natural world. Limonene exists in cannabis plants as well as lemons, oranges, and junipers, to name a few. Strains with a high concentration of limonene deliver a citrus taste and smell while providing an uplifting experience.

[Aroma & Effects]

  • Energizing
  • Citrus aroma
  • Stress relieving
  • Anti-inflammatory, antioxidant, antiseptic

[Popular Strains]

  • Tangerine Dream
  • Pre-98 Bubba Kush
  • GSC (Cookies)
  • Tangerine Dream

Myrcene

Myrcene is another common terpene found in cannabis as well as mangos, hops, lemongrass, and thyme. Myrcene has been shown to reduce resistance in the blood-brain barrier, which allows the body to easily absorb marijuana’s full spectrum of cannabinoids. Additionally, Myrcene yields individual therapeutic benefits.

[Aroma & Effects]

  • Sedative
  • Earthy aroma
  • Relaxing
  • Pain reliever, anti-inflammatory, antioxidant

[Popular Strains]

  • Chemdawg
  • Grape Stomper
  • Fire Alien Kush
  • Agent Orange

Pinene

Pinene is found in cannabis, pine trees, rosemary and sage. It’s an antiseptic agent and is known as a natural bug repellent. Pinene is also known to help counteract memory impairment caused by high levels of THC. Similar to limonene, Pinene is also more energizing.

[Aroma & Effects]

  • Energizing
  • Woody aroma
  • Promotes memory retention
  • Bronchodilator, anti-inflammatory, antiseptic

[Popular Strains]

  • Vanilla Kush
  • Cookie Cross
  • 9lb Hammer
  • Lavender

Linalool

Linalool is a floral terpene found in cannabis as well as lavender, basil, orange flower, and coriander. It delivers relaxing, anti-anxiety effects and can be found in some of the most popular strains.

[Aroma & Effects]

  • Anti-Inflammatory
  • Floral aroma
  • Anti-convulsant
  • Pain reliever

[Popular Strains]

  • Bubble Gum
  • 9lb Hammer
  • Sour Diesel
  • Locomotion

The Trouble With Cannabis Terpenes

The presence of terpenes are vital to experience whole-plant medicinal benefits of marijuana, but they’re also unpredictable. Cannabis plants contain hundreds of terpenes and each plant contains a different mix at varying concentration levels. Even two batches of the same strain can contain a different terpene profile, depending on where and how it’s grown.

For example, plants grown outdoors have a higher percentage of overall terpenes due to the differences that natural sunlight and environmental stressors yield. Outdoor cannabis also produces more terpenes, like Pinene to repel bugs and thrive in this challenging environment.  

In addition to variability, cannabis terpenes are also extremely volatile. Without proper drying and curing processes, terpenes can easily evaporate making it difficult to extract.

The process of extracting cannabis flower terpenes is also extremely expensive and often yields a much lower quantity than extraction from other plants. This expensive, inefficient process means higher price tags for customers. So as the demand for flavorful whole-plant products grows, modern cannabis companies have turned to nature’s mangos, lemons, and pine trees for support.

The Modernist Argument

The process of extracting the same cannabis terpenes from other plants is simple, cost-effective, and more consistent because manufacturers can use the same compounds each time they create the product. Plant terpenes also taste and smell bolder, because they exist in a higher volume in other plants than in cannabis. Adding a higher volume of terpenes to concentrates also improves viscosity, which makes it more convenient for vape cartridges too.

Non-cannabis terpenes also enable more innovation by allowing companies to recreate strains that no longer exist in nature. One recent example is the Gainesville Green strain, a wildly popular variety from the late 1970s and into the 1980s. Working directly with Rick Naya, Gainesville Green’s original creator, Sunshine Cannabis developed a blend of plant-based terpenes to recreate Gainesville's original profile and relaunched it in Trulieve dispensaries across Florida. The benefits of plant-based terpenes are clear, so what’s the downside?

The Purist Argument

Isolated terpenes of the same type are equal in terms of chemical makeup. Despite that fact, cannabis purists argue that blending cannabinoids (like THC and CBD) with non-cannabis terpenes is unnatural and potentially unsafe at high concentrations. According to Chemical News & Engineering, some companies are infusing products with non-cannabis plant terpenes at concentrations much higher than naturally found in cannabis flowers.

At concentrations above 15%, these products might be irritating to the skin and lungs. But even when cannabis companies are careful to use safe concentration levels, purists argue that these products are still lacking the health benefits provided by the whole plant.

According to the argument, cannabis-derived terpenes are more effective because they contain trace elements of other compounds found in cannabis that would not exist in other plant terpenes. These synergize to enhance the product’s medicinal value via The Entourage Effect. Therefore, pure flower extracts not only deliver the aromatic and flavor profile, but they also maximize the psychoactive and therapeutic benefits.

Concluding the Debate

The debate between innovation and purity in the cannabis industry is just beginning. Modernists believe they can create infusions that mimic cannabis’s whole cannabinoid and terpene concentrations. Modernists cite that as long as the terpenes come from food-grade quality plants and match the original cannabis profiles, their products are safe.

Additionally, the cost savings and enhanced flavor appeals to consumer demand for affordable products. Purists may have an argument regarding the therapeutic value of cannabis-derived terpenes, but they currently lack scientific research surrounding the potential dangers of using alternatives.

For consumers, the bottom line is to always purchase products from trusted companies. In the meantime, the team at ACS Laboratory will continue to follow the debate and report any research related to cannabis vs. non-cannabis terpenes. We believe that labeling products with their terpene profiles is a great way to drive value, so if you’d like to take that next step we’d be excited to be involved.

Drop us a line, any time at (813) 634-4529, or go here to contact us online.

The Cannabinoids Guide

This complete cannabinoid guide covers major and minor cannabinoids, how they work in the body, and highlights the top compounds brands and operators must test for today.
Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.

The Cannabinoid Guide

The definitive resource on leading major and minor cannabinoids, how they work in the body, and what to test for.
Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.

Related Blogs

February 2, 2023

A Guide to Delta-8 vs. THCOa: Extraction, Products, Safety, Legality, Testing & More

Comparing Delta-8 THC and THCOa’s chemistry, effects, potency, and extraction methods.

Elena Schmidt

January 30, 2023

ACS Laboratory Receives 82 Emerald Badges for Exemplary Hemp and Cannabis Test Results, More Than Any Laboratory in the USA

Recently Awarded 21 Emerald Test Proficiency Badges for 2022, ACS has Reaffirmed its Position as the Most Trusted Third-party Hemp and Cannabis Testing Provider

ACS Laboratory

January 25, 2023

Comparing Exotic Cannabinoids: Delta-9 THC vs. Delta-8, Delta-10, HHC, HHCP, THC-O (THCOa), & THCP

The main difference between exotic cannabinoids and Delta-9 THC is their molecular structures, psychoactive intensity, and legality.

Elena Schmidt

December 29, 2022

A Guide to Delta-8 vs. HHC: Extraction, Products, Safety, Legality, Testing & More

Delta-8 THC is a mildly euphoric psychoactive isomer of Delta-9 THC. HHC belongs to a completely different chemical class known as hexahydrocannabinol. Learn more.

Elena Schmidt

January 19, 2023

Amanita Muscaria Part II: Active Ingredients, Effects, Nutrition & Legality

Exploring amanita muscaria’s psychoactive effects, toxic potential, edible preparation, and legality in the US and Canada.

Masha Ty

January 13, 2023

Cannabis Concentrates 101: A Guide to Terms, Usage, Potency, and Testing

Explaining the differences between cannabis concentrate types–from potency to usage to equipment and safety.

Elena Schmidt

January 5, 2023

Functional Mushrooms: Exploring Lion’s Mane, Cordyceps, and Reishi Benefits & Uses

Reviewing functional mushroom benefits, research, and top products, with a focus on reishi, lion’s mane, and cordyceps.

Masha Ty

January 3, 2023

Terpene Tuesdays: Everything You Need to Know About Farnesene Flavor, Fragrance, and Benefits

Farnesene is a cannabis terpene known as sesquiterpenes and is thought to have sedative and regulating effects on the human body and mood.

Elena Schmidt

December 9, 2022

INTERVIEW: Live Rosin Delta-8: How It's Made, Effects, Safety & Quality

Live rosin delta 8 is a cannabis concentrate made from frozen plant material and manufactured delta-8 extract. Learn more.

December 20, 2022

Terpene Tuesdays: Everything You Need to Know About Camphene Flavor, Fragrance, and Benefits

Research suggests that camphene possesses anti-microbial and antiviral properties, provides coughing relief, and may even be able to prevent heart disease.

Elena Schmidt

December 16, 2022

Amanita Muscaria (Fly Agaric): History & Toxicology of the Most Misunderstood Mushroom

Amanita mushrooms are fully legal in the United States and have a long history of use. Discovery Amanita mythology and toxicology in this ACS blog.

Masha Ty

December 14, 2022

Visit the New and Improved ACS Laboratory Website

Enhanced education, intuitive navigation, mushroom program launch, compliance updates, and more!

Elena Schmidt

December 8, 2022

Companies Producing Edibles Containing CBD and Delta-8 THC Receive New Warning Letters from the FDA

FDA recently issued new warning letters to companies that produce CBD and Delta-8 THC edibles.

December 1, 2022

THCP: Guide to THCP Effects, Products, Legality, Testing, and More

THCP has a 30X stronger binding affinity to ECS receptors than Delta-9 THC, marijuana's most abundant and powerful psychoactive agent.